Mudcrutch 2016 NYC Concert: ‘This is Far Out’—Review

Share This:
Tom Petty of Mudcrutch, June 10, 2016 at NYC's Webster Hall (Photo: Greg Brodsky)

Tom Petty of Mudcrutch, June 10, 2016 at NYC’s Webster Hall (Photo ©  Greg Brodsky)

Our 2016 review from Mudcrutch’s brief tour of smaller-sized venues.

From the reaction of the jam-packed crowd at NYC’s Webster Hall on June 10, 2016, you would have never known that Tom Petty had another band. Because on this night the five-piece Mudcrutch – supplemented live with a sixth member, and for three songs, a seventh… more on that in a moment – absolutely crushed it.

With two albums now under their belts, 2008’s Mudcrutch and their excellent follow-up, 2, the country-rock band has more than enough material to create a 20-plus song set, which included several well-chosen covers.

Related: Review of Mudcrutch’s “real fine” 2nd album

Petty, McGuinn, Leadon and Pedersen (Photo: Greg Brodsky)

Petty, McGuinn, Leadon and Pedersen (Photo © Greg Brodsky)

One of those covers was “Lover Of The Bayou” co-written by Roger McGuinn and for good reason: The Byrds’ co-founder and key Petty influence was a surprise guest on this occasion. McGuinn easily looks and sounds 15 years’ younger than his 73 years; he and Petty shared lead vocals on the song, which Mudcrutch covered on their 2008 debut.

Afterwards, Petty exclaimed, “This is far out!” McGuinn’s final number with the band was a stellar cover of Bob Dylan’s “You Ain’t Goin’ Nowhere.”

[McGuinn’s performance on this night and the next, at the same venue, proved to be his last with Petty.]

Mike Campbell and Tom Petty

Mike Campbell and Tom Petty (Photo © Greg Brodsky)

For the uninitiated, Mudcrutch was formed in 1970 by Petty and his teenage pal, Tom Leadon (brother of Eagle Bernie Leadon). Among the other early members were drummer Randall Marsh and the future Heartbreakers, guitarist Mike Campbell and keyboardist Benmont Tench.

The team concept of the band allows each member to write and sing lead on at least one song and following Tench’s turn on his “Welcome to Hell” from the new album, the enthusiastic crowd shouted “Ben-mont, Ben-mont” to which an approving Petty added: “I do that in the shower.”

Leadon’s contribution, “The Other Side of the Mountain,” which he described as the “first psychedelic bluegrass song,” featured a terrific, long jam including one from Campbell as well as beautiful banjo-picking by the touring band’s sixth member, the veteran bluegrass musician Herb Pedersen.

Any thoughts of hearing a signature song like “American Girl” or “Free Fallin'” from Petty’s “other” band were dashed within the night’s first few songs; they simply wouldn’t fit in with Mudcrutch’s repertoire, and frankly weren’t missed. (Ironically, Petty was honored the night before with induction into the Songwriters Hall of Fame for his enormous and remarkable body of work.)

In talking about the band’s early days, Petty said: “When we first started out, we played clubs just like this… five shows a night, six days a week. But the people who worked there were topless.”

Mudcrutch, Webster Hall, NYC, June 10, 2016 (via

Shady Grove
Orphan of the Storm
Six Days on the Road
Scare Easy
This is a Good Street
Beautiful World
Dreams of Flying
Save Your Water
Hungry No More
I Forgive It All
Knockin’ on Heaven’s Door
Lover of the Bayou (with Roger McGuinn)
Bugler (with Roger McGuinn)
You Ain’t Goin’ Nowhere (with Roger McGuinn)
The Other Side of the Mountain
Welcome to Hell
Victim of Circumstance
The Wrong Thing To Do
Bootleg Flyer

Crystal River

Watch them perform “Trailer”

Mudcrutch’s recordings are available here.

Greg Brodsky

3 Comments so far

Jump into a conversation
  1. CC
    #1 CC 4 January, 2019, 01:34

    Those were some great shows. I saw Mudcrutch in Philadelphia at the Fillmore in June 2016 and it was a fantastic concert!

    Reply this comment
    • Carrie♥️Gainesville
      Carrie♥️Gainesville 12 June, 2021, 06:49

      Mudcrutch was from Gainesville, Florida & regularly played at Dub’s Nightclub & Bar. They were considered to be “The House Band”!!! I was about 4yrs old when my Mom worked there as part-time bartender in the early 1970’s. When my Dad & I would come to pick up my Mom from work around closing time, sometimes he would get there early. Instead of waiting in the car for Mom to come out, if we were early he would bring me in with him into the bar. While my Mom was cleaning up the bar area at closing time,Tom Petty & The rest of the band members of Mudcrutch would still be up on Stage playing or just hanging out with Dub at the bar! I remember bits & pieces of seeing & hearing them play! I did finally get to see Tom Petty in concert here in Gainesville, Fl.
      It was in 1982 at the Stephen C O’Connor Center not long after it was built! Stevie Nicks showed up as a surprise guest & together they sang her hit “Stop Dragging My Heart Around” and 3 other songs! What a Show! I went on to see him & The Heartbreakers live in concert 8 more times!!! All of us in Gainesville, Fl still miss him greatly!
      He was one of us,
      A “Gainesvillean”!
      A truly gifted song writer, A talented guitar player, A musician whom was dedicated to his craft. He Loved to play Live shows for his many fans! We hope that he now knows we Loved him for that & much more!!!
      Tom Petty! RIP!!!

      Reply this comment
  2. Chris
    #2 Chris 11 June, 2022, 02:06

    I miss Petty and the Heartbreakers shows along with Mudcrutch. Always fun to sing along with these great musicians!
    At least we still have Mike Campbell and the Dirty Knobs!

    Reply this comment

Your data will be safe!Your e-mail address will not be published. Also other data will not be shared with third person.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.