An Expanded Edition of the Beatles’ ‘Anthology Collection’: Review
by Jeff Burger
How on Earth did The Beatles progress from songs like “I Want to Hold Your Hand” to “Strawberry Fields Forever” and “Penny Lane” in only a little more than three years? The sparks that ignite artistic growth can be enigmatic, but the Fab Four’s Anthology album series, released in the mid-1990s, did help to flesh out their story. Featuring a total of 155 previously unreleased tracks on three two-CD sets, it provided new insights into the group’s creative process via demos, alternate takes, outtakes and audition, rehearsal and live performances.
Three decades later, the band’s surviving members and their label have freshened up and expanded the series. The new Anthology Collection includes versions of the original three sets that have been remastered by producer George Martin’s son, Giles, who in recent years has overseen the development of boxed sets devoted to five of the Beatles’ most beloved LPs. In addition, the new release introduces a fourth two-CD set, also curated by Giles.
The first three sets come with the 48-page booklets that accompanied the original Anthology collections. They each include photos and notes by Beatles expert Mark Lewisohn. Anthology 4 features a similar 48-page booklet, but the notes for this one are by British producer Kevin Howlett. (Lewisohn, who is working on the second volume of his gargantuan, incredibly detailed Beatles history, was presumably too busy to contribute.) You’ll also find lots of discographic information in the booklets, and you should rely on them for song credits, because the discs’ metadata is riddled with inaccuracies.
If you’re a Beatles fan (and who isn’t?) and don’t already own the first three compendiums, the Anthology Collection should prove irresistible. If you have volumes one, two and three, however, the new set’s remasters, while offering significant sonic improvements, probably don’t provide enough justification to upgrade. So, you’ll be glad to know that, while the initial plan was to offer Anthology 4 only in a package with its three predecessors, Apple Records yielded to fan pressure and has made it available separately.
We’ll talk presently about that fourth set, but first, for those who don’t own the earlier volumes, let’s look at what they offer.
Anthology 1 opens with what at the time of its release was something new: “Free as a Bird,” a likable single that the surviving Beatles built in 1994 on the foundation of a 1977 John Lennon demo. After that, the set turns the clock way back to 1958 to open a window on the Fab Four’s creation. We hear a cover of Buddy Holly’s “That’ll Be the Day” and “In Spite of All the Danger,” a Lennon/George Harrison composition, both performed by the Quarrymen, the group that evolved into the Beatles. Here, too, are several tracks that feature original bassist Stu Sutcliffe or drummer Pete Best, recordings from the Beatles’ 1961 stint in Hamburg, Germany, and five numbers from the group’s unsuccessful Decca audition. Also featured are 17 live performances from 1963 and 1964, and alternate takes of such early originals as “Eight Days a Week,” “No Reply” and “A Hard Day’s Night.”
Like its predecessor, Anthology 2 opens with a newly created track, “Real Love,” which consists of a 1980 Lennon recording with 1995 embellishments by his surviving bandmates. After that, the set picks up where Anthology 1 leaves off, delivering demos, outtakes and alternate versions of songs that show the group growing creatively at a breakneck pace. These numbers come from the sessions for Help!, Rubber Soul, Yellow Submarine, Revolver, Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band, and Magical Mystery Tour, and include versions of classics such as “Yesterday,” “Eleanor Rigby,” “Strawberry Fields Forever,” “Penny Lane” and “The Fool on the Hill.” There are also a few live tracks, among them “Everybody’s Trying to Be My Baby,” from the Beatles’ famous 1965 show at New York’s Shea Stadium.
Anthology 3, which draws its program almost entirely from 1968 and 1969, predominantly features home demos and alternate takes of songs from Abbey Road, Let It Be, and the eponymous double LP widely known as The White Album. There are also a few originals that the Beatles had not previously released, such as “Step Inside Love,” which Cilla Black once recorded, and “What’s the New Mary Jane,” as well as covers of songs such as “Blue Suede Shoes” and “Ain’t She Sweet.” Another attraction is a demo version of the song that would become the title track on George Harrison’s All Things Must Pass.
A remix of “The End,” the last full-length track on Abbey Road, concludes the album. Until now, it also concluded the Anthology series, but as noted above, a fourth package has just been released. Unlike the first three volumes, which respectively cover the Beatles’ early, middle and later years, Anthology 4 includes material from their entire career.
This 44-track compilation is a bit of a disappointment compared with its three predecessors, partly because it contains only 13 previously unreleased tracks, even though more remain in the vaults. Dominating the program are recordings culled from expanded editions of Revolver, Sgt. Pepper’s, The Beatles, Abbey Road and Let It Be, as well as new mixes by Jeff Lynne of “Free as a Bird” and “Real Love.” All this material is worth hearing, however, so, especially if you don’t have those excellent but pricey earlier boxes, you might well want to pick up Anthology 4.
Related: Another take on Anthology 4
That said, let’s hope that Giles Martin and his associates will now turn their attention to something with the potential to be more revelatory than this fourth Anthology volume. One suspects, for example, that more than a few Beatles fans are eagerly awaiting a box set devoted to the sessions for Rubber Soul.
The 12-LP and 8-CD editions of the Beatles’ Anthology Collection are available in the U.S./worldwide here, in Canada here and in the U.K. here. Anthology 4 is available as a standalone 3-LP or 2-CD set in the U.S./worldwide here, in Canada here and in the U.K. here.
Burger wrote one of the first interview-based profiles of Bruce Springsteen to be published in a national magazine. He has interviewed many other music-world luminaries as well, including Steve Van Zandt, Roger McGuinn, John Sebastian, Wolfman Jack, Tom Waits, Foreigner’s Mick Jones, Billy Joel, Steve Forbert, Tommy James, the Righteous Brothers, Gordon Lightfoot, Deep Purple’s Tommy Bolin, and members of Steely Dan and the Marshall Tucker Band. He has also interviewed many other public figures, such as Suze Orman, Daymond John, James Carville, Donald Trump, Sir Richard Branson, F. Lee Bailey, and Cliff Robertson.
His books include Dylan on Dylan: Interviews and Encounters, Lennon on Lennon: Conversations with John Lennon, Leonard Cohen on Leonard Cohen: Interviews and Encounters, and Springsteen on Springsteen: Interviews, Speeches, and Encounters, all of which are published in the U.S. and Canada by Chicago Review Press. The books have been republished in numerous other countries.
Burger has been the editor of several periodicals, including Business Jet Traveler, from which he retired in 2024. During his 20 years at that
publication, it received more than 120 major editorial awards, including multiple wins for the world’s Best Consumer Travel Magazine in the annual Folio:Eddie competition.
Burger lives in Ridgewood, New Jersey. His wife, Madeleine Beresford, is a puppeteer and former preschool director and teacher. The couple have two grown children.
No Comments so far
Jump into a conversationNo Comments Yet!
You can be the one to start a conversation.